News

When does a landlord unreasonably withhold consent to tenant alterations?

In Messenex Property Investments Ltd v Lanark Square Ltd [2024] EWHC 89 the High Court considered whether the landlord, Lanark, had unreasonably withheld consent for alterations requested by the tenant, Messenex.

Messenex’s proposed building works included rooftop and ground floor modifications, and the landlord’s prior consent written was required under the lease “not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed”.

Messenex’s requests for consent began in 2020 and Lanark requested further information to be able to consider the request. This correspondence went on for almost 3 years until Messenex referred the matter to the Court.

Key issues revolved around the tenant’s failure to provide necessary structural engineer’s drawings, and its refusal to offer an unconditional undertaking for the landlord’s legal costs. The Court found that Lanark’s concern about the structural impact of the works was valid. Therefore, the landlord’s decision to withhold consent was seen as reasonable, primarily due to the lack of vital documentation from the tenant and concerns over the building’s structural integrity.

The judgment highlighted that landlords are not obliged to grant consent if the tenant has not met reasonable requests, such as providing critical information about the proposed alterations. This ruling follows principles established in earlier cases, where some reasonable grounds for withholding consent can suffice, even if other grounds are unreasonable.

This case reinforces that when seeking consent for alterations, tenants must fulfil reasonable requests to avoid disputes.

 

Posted on 09/09/2024 by Ortolan

Get in Touch

If you would like to know more about Ortolan Legal and how we can help you reduce your ongoing recruitment costs, get in touch!

Email us now

   Or call 020 3743 0600

Unipart Group has used Ortolan Legal’s services to supplement our in-house legal team for a number of years. We keep coming back to them because their unique combination of experienced, high quality lawyers at extremely cost-effective rates sets them apart from other law firms. It also has to be said that their team are personable, highly commercial and very responsive. I would recommend them without reservation.

Richard Collins, Group Legal Director Unipart
See All
Receive news & updates from Ortolan Legal

Meet the Team

  • Nick Benson Nick Benson I qualified as a commercial and corporate solicitor…
  • Liz Delgado Liz Delgado I qualified as a solicitor in 1995 after studying…
  • Carrie Beaumont Carrie Beaumont I qualified as an Employment specialist in 2008. I…